So if olive oil can help you keep your gums healthy, should you switch to that for oil pulling? Not necessarily, says a small study recently published in the Journal of Orofacial Research.
Thirty-four adults took part, half of whom were told to pull with coconut oil once a day after brushing and half of whom were told to do the same with olive oil. Each participant also had measures of dental plaque and gum health taken throughout the study period, which lasted for 30 days total.
Both groups saw improvements. However,
coconut oil showed a significant decrease in plaque and gingival scores in comparison to olive oil in patients with mild to moderate gingivitis.
That is, those who pulled with coconut oil had less plaque buildup and less inflammation in their gums than those in the olive oil group.
This adds to the growing body of evidence suggesting that coconut oil may be one of the best options for pulling. We’ve blogged about some of this research before, and later studies have reinforced those good results. For instance, a recent review of the science in the journal Heliyon, analyzed data from several randomized controlled trials which showed, overall, that
oil pulling with coconut oil may have a beneficial effect on improving oral health and dental hygiene….[and] could be used as an adjunct to normal preventative regimes to improve oral health and dental hygiene although further studies are needed to determine the level of effectiveness.
In general, oil pulling has been found to have a number of oral health benefits, including better plaque control, healthier gums, reduced halitosis (bad breath), and reduced oral thrush. Some studies have shown coconut oil to be at least as effective as chlorhexidine rinse, with none of the risks of staining. Others, such as this Egyptian study, suggest it could be even better, While both coconut oil and chlorhexidine reduced S. mutans in the mouth – one of the main bacteria involved in tooth decay – coconut oil reduced it more. Its authors thus concluded that
coconut oil pulling therapy may be used as preventive therapy at home to maintain oral hygiene as it is natural, safe and has no side effects.
As Dr. Mike says, “It may sound too good to be true, but quite honestly you have nothing to lose and everything to gain by trying it.”
Ready to start? This post tells you how.
How does coconut oil for oil pulling compare with the traditional sesame oil recommended for thousands of years in Ayurvedic Medicine? And data?
Each has its benefits. For instance, while both oils have been found effective against S. mutans, coconut oil also appears helpful against Candida albicans, while sesame oil is helpful against Lactobacilli. But some studies have found coconut oil to be more effective for specific outcomes, such as reducing gingivitis, as in the study abstracted here: https://www.jnsbm.org/article.asp?issn=0976-9668;year=2018;volume=9;issue=2;spage=165;epage=168;aulast=Kaliamoorthy;_ga=2.143080435.753810930.1582319500-909402922.1582319500. This is one of the few head-to-head studies we’re aware of, though. Much of the literature to date focuses on either one or the other – or oil pulling in general.